Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Legal Services Corp Case

The LSC is a government agency that "distributes funds appropriated by Congress to eligible local grantee organizations" to fund legal services for the poor. The law provides that the funds may not be used "if the representation involves an effort to amend or otherwise challenge existing welfare law."

Is this case more like Rust (funding private grantees to deliver government speech or government services) or more like Rosenberger (funding that facilitates private speech, in this case the private legal arguments of clients challenging governmental restrictions on welfare programs)? See page1619.

In a lawsuit challenging governmental restrictions in a welfare program, which lawyer delivers the government's legal viewpoint--the government's lawyer or the LSC-funded lawyer representing the welfare applicant? See id.

See p. 1619-1620:

1. " The private nature of the speech involved here, and the extent of the LSC's regulation of private expression, are indicated further by the circumstance that the Government seeks to use an existing medium of expression and to control it, in a class of cases, in ways which distort its usual functioning."

2. "Restricting LSC attorneys in advising their clients and in presenting arguments and analyses to the courts distorts the legal system by altering the traditional role of attorneys."

Now apply this to the Promise Scholarship Program in Locke v. Davey. Is this a pool of funds designed to facilitate private educational speech or is it government speech? Is the restriction against funding "devotional theology" majors a viewpoint restriction on private educational speech? Does it "distort" an "existing private medium of expression?"

Is Davey more like Rust or more like Rosenberger, Finley and Velazquez? If Rehnquist was really serious in avoiding a free speech issue in Davey, his job was to analyze this cases and persuasively argue that Davey was more like Rust than like the others. Did he do so?

Thursday, May 24, 2012

Our Course in the News

Today's Wall Street Journal (link):

Catholics in Court

The religious-liberty lawsuit against ObamaCare is historic. 

 

 The 12 federal lawsuits filed Monday by 43 Catholic plaintiffs against the Obama Administration's birth-control mandate are a big political and Constitutional moment. The nation's most prominent Catholic institutions are saying that the same federal government they have viewed for decades as an ally in their fight for social justice is now a threat to their religious liberty.

This can't have been an easy decision, especially because the plaintiffs are hardly founding members of the tea party. They include the Archdioceses of New York and Washington but also Catholic University in Washington, D.C., and even the University of Notre Dame.

The famously liberal Notre Dame gave President Obama an honorary degree in 2009 despite his support for abortion rights. At the time, Notre Dame President John Jenkins applauded Mr. Obama's "willingness to engage with those who disagree with him and encourage people of faith to bring their beliefs to the public debate."

So much for that. The lawsuit signals that far from engaging with "those who disagree," Mr. Obama has rebuffed Catholic leaders in their attempt to work out a compromise over the Administration's mandate that all insurance plans offer contraception and sterilization services, including abortifacients. "If the government wants to provide such services," Father Jenkins said in a statement Monday, "means are available that do not compel religious organizations to serve as its agents."

 But the Administration deliberately rejected any such means, exempting a religious employer only if it is a nonprofit whose goal is the "inculcation of religious values" and which primarily employs and serves people who share the same values. That leaves out legions of parochial schools, universities, hospitals, soup kitchens and other charities whose beliefs are also threatened by the mandate.

The Department of Health and Human Services offered a fig leaf in February, foisting the mandate onto insurance companies rather than religious employers. But the insurers would pass along the mandate's cost to the employers in any case, and institutions like Notre Dame that self-insure would still be subsidizing policies that violate core church teaching. As Cardinal Timothy Dolan of New York put it, this so-called "safe habor" effectively gives religious institutions "a year to figure out how to violate [their] consciences."
The suit charges that the mandate violates the First Amendment's Free Exercise Clause, as well as the 1993 Religious Freedom Restoration Act, which requires that the federal government meet a higher legal standard for any law that interferes with religious liberty. "If the Government can force religious institutions to violate their beliefs in such a manner," argues the Notre Dame suit, "there is no apparent limit to the Government's power."
The Administration and Democrats have tried to obscure the real nature of this dispute by claiming that the church wants to deny contraception to women. But birth control will continue to be widely available and easily affordable no matter what the legal outcome. Nine out of 10 health plans currently provide it.
The real and startling question at issue is whether the entitlement state can pound everything, including religious belief, to its political will. Few previous Administrations would have dared such a high-stakes Constitutional battle, but Mr. Obama's willfulness reveals the change that is taking place in liberal politics.
 Once upon a time the political left viewed Catholics and especially the bishops as their allies in using government to create more equal opportunity and redistribute income. But today's Democratic Party puts a higher cultural value on sexual politics and expanded reproductive freedom. We trust the courts will instruct the Administration that the Constitution still puts religious liberty first.

Monday, May 21, 2012

Class Schedule

I checked with Vickie this morning. Here is the remainder of our schedule.

We meet every day this week.

Monday May 28--No class Memorial Day Holiday

Tuesday May 29--Regular class

Wednesday May 30--Regular Class (last scheduled class)

Thursday May 31--No class scheduled. Study for Final

Friday June 1--Final Exam (8:30 AM)

Sunday, May 20, 2012

For Monday May 21

Let's start Monday's class with a discussion of education and religious liberty and justice from a Rawlisian consensus from behind the "veil of ignorance." Scroll down to next post.

We will break up into small groups and, writing from a blank slate, try to reach a consensus as to how to structure the role of government in the new society we are creating.

You won't know what your situation will be like in this new society.

You might be a committed secularist or Christian or Jew or Buddhist or atheist or some other religious or non-religious believer.

You may be rich or poor or somewhere in between.

Whatever your beliefs, you love your children and want them to be educated about what is true and good and beautiful. And you also understand that we do not agree about many of these truths, or indeed, even about the nature of reason and rationality.
 
 Consider, for example, brilliant scholars such as Profs. Ackerman and Johnson and their very different worldviews. If you and they had to design an educational system from "behind the veil of ignorance" how would you reach a consensus about how to design it?


Thursday, May 17, 2012

A Call for Religious Freedom


Here is the text of George Weigel's recent Commencement Address, delivered at Benedictine College, entitled "Defending Religious Freedom in Full: A Generation's Challenge."It has generated a great deal of buzz lately.

Link

Today (Wed. May 16)

Let's start today's class with a discussion of the John Spokes hypo in Handout 2.

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

Incorporation of Individual Liberty

I think I went too quickly over the issue of Incorporation of the EC yesterday.

I want to start today's class by going back over the theory of incorporation, which is that individual liberty interests from the Bill of Rights are "incorporated" against the states because these are fundamental individual liberties.

However, in many EC cases the state law being challenged as a violation of the EC is not one that deprives anyone of liberty. Indeed, it often seems as though the court is being asked not to advance individual liberty but to restrict individual liberty in order to carry out some structural rule concerning state power (such as Lemon's rule that laws must have a "secular purpose"--this doesn't ask "whose liberty is being restricted, but rather "does the state have the power to enact laws if the legislature lacks a "secular purpose').

Think about Everson, Zorach, and the cases we read for today. Ask yourself is the EC being brandished to protect liberty, or to take liberty away?

Thursday, May 10, 2012

New Look For Blog

I decided to do a little interior decorating and gave the blog a new template.

I like it!

Tuesday, May 08, 2012

Handouts Available

The Handouts referred to in the list of Assignments are available in the Handout Racks near the South Side faculty Suite.

Sunday, March 04, 2012

Recent Equal Access Case Filed

From RelgionClause blog:

Suit Filed Over Library's Room Use Policy

The religious education and advocacy organization, Liberty Counsel, last month filed a federal lawsuit against the Seaside, Oregon public library after being denied use of a library meeting room for a planned program on educating children from a Biblical perspective.  The complaint (full text) in Liberty Counsel, Inc. v. Seaside Public Library Board of Trustees, (D OR, filed 2/9/2012), alleges that the library's room-use policy violates the 1st Amendment's free expression and establishment clauses, as well as the equal protection clause of the 14th Amendment. Under the library's rules, rooms are available for non-profit groups to use, but use for religious services or proselytizing is not permitted. The Astoria (OR) Daily Astorian reports on the lawsuit.

Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Montana Constitution--Every 20 Years the People Look Under the Hood

Article XIV Constitutional Revision

Section 1. Constitutional convention. The legislature, by an affirmative vote of two-thirds of all the members, whether one or more bodies, may at any time submit to the qualified electors the question of whether there shall be an unlimited convention to revise, alter, or amend this constitution.

Section 2. Initiative for constitutional convention. (1) The people may by initiative petition direct the secretary of state to submit to the qualified electors the question of whether there shall be an unlimited convention to revise, alter, or amend this constitution. The petition shall be signed by at least ten percent of the qualified electors of the state. That number shall include at least ten percent of the qualified electors in each of two-fifths of the legislative districts.
(2) The secretary of state shall certify the filing of the petition in his office and cause the question to be submitted at the next general election.

Section 3. Periodic submission. If the question of holding a convention is not otherwise submitted during any period of 20 years, it shall be submitted as provided by law at the general election in the twentieth year following the last submission.

Section 4. Call of convention. If a majority of those voting on the question answer in the affirmative, the legislature shall provide for the calling thereof at its next session. The number of delegates to the convention shall be the same as that of the larger body of the legislature. The qualifications of delegates shall be the same as the highest qualifications required for election to the legislature. The legislature shall determine whether the delegates may be nominated on a partisan or a non-partisan basis. They shall be elected at the same places and in the same districts as are the members of the legislative body determining the number of delegates.

Section 5. Convention expenses. The legislature shall, in the act calling the convention, designate the day, hour, and place of its meeting, and fix and provide for the pay of its members and officers and the necessary expenses of the convention.

Section 6. Oath, vacancies. Before proceeding, the delegates shall take the oath provided in this constitution. Vacancies occurring shall be filled in the manner provided for filling vacancies in the legislature if not otherwise provided by law.

Section 7. Convention duties. The convention shall meet after the election of the delegates and prepare such revisions, alterations, or amendments to the constitution as may be deemed necessary. They shall be submitted to the qualified electors for ratification or rejection as a whole or in separate articles or amendments as determined by the convention at an election appointed by the convention for that purpose not less than two months after adjournment. Unless so submitted and approved by a majority of the electors voting thereon, no such revision, alteration, or amendment shall take effect.

Section 8. Amendment by legislative referendum. Amendments to this constitution may be proposed by any member of the legislature. If adopted by an affirmative roll call vote of two-thirds of all the members thereof, whether one or more bodies, the proposed amendment shall be submitted to the qualified electors at the next general election. If approved by a majority of the electors voting thereon, the amendment shall become a part of this constitution on the first day of July after certification of the election returns unless the amendment provides otherwise.

Section 9. Amendment by initiative. (1) The people may also propose constitutional amendments by initiative. Petitions including the full text of the proposed amendment shall be signed by at least ten percent of the qualified electors of the state. That number shall include at least ten percent of the qualified electors in each of at least one-half of the counties.
(2) The petitions shall be filed with the secretary of state. If the petitions are found to have been signed by the required number of electors, the secretary of state shall cause the amendment to be published as provided by law twice each month for two months previous to the next regular state-wide election.
(3) At that election, the proposed amendment shall be submitted to the qualified electors for approval or rejection. If approved by a majority voting thereon, it shall become a part of the constitution effective the first day of July following its approval, unless the amendment provides otherwise.
History: Amd. Const. Amend. No. 37, approved Nov. 5, 2002.

Section 10. Petition signers. The number of qualified electors required for the filing of any petition provided for in this Article shall be determined by the number of votes cast for the office of governor in the preceding general election.

Section 11. Submission. If more than one amendment is submitted at the same election, each shall be so prepared and distinguished that it can be voted upon separately.

Done in open convention at the city of Helena, in the state of Montana, this twenty-second day of March, in the year of our Lord one thousand nine hundred and seventy-two.

Sunday, January 22, 2012

Wednesday Jan. 25--Federalism

Here are some questions I would like you to think about for this week's class.

1. What exactly is federalism under the U S Constitution?

2. Which provisions or structural designs of the Constitution  provide for federalism?

3. What are the benefits and the costs of federalism? What is the difference between centralized authority and local authority?

4. Is the original balance between centralized authority and state authority still recognized? Which provisions or judicial decisions are responsible for shifting the original design?

5.In Federalist No. 45 Madison said:


The powers delegated by the proposed Constitution to the federal government, are few and defined. Those which are to remain in the State governments are numerous and indefinite. The former will be exercised principally on external objects, as war, peace, negotiation, and foreign commerce; with which last the power of taxation will, for the most part, be connected. The powers reserved to the several States will extend to all the objects which, in the ordinary course of affairs, concern the lives, liberties, and properties of the people, and the internal order, improvement, and prosperity of the State.

Re-write Madison's description to describe the relative powers of the federal government and the states in the the times or our lives.

6. What, if anything should we do to restore the originally designed balance of power?

Thursday, December 01, 2011

Romer and the Nebraska Marriage Amendment

In Romer, the Court said that Colorado Amendment 2 failed rational basis review because the nearly infinite breadth of the amendment was not rationally related to the legitimate state interests of protecting the liberty of landlords and employers from restrictive gay rights laws. See p. 998-1000. In other words, the means employed were extremely overinclusive with respect to the legitimate governmental purpose of economic liberty. How does Romer apply to the Nebraska Marriage Amendment?

The Nebraska Constitution (art. I, sec. 29) provides:


Only marriage between a man and a woman shall be valid or recognized in Nebraska. The uniting of two persons of the same sex in a civil union, domestic partnership, or other similar same-sex relationship shall not be valid or recognized in Nebraska.
Neb. Const. art. I, sec. 29 (2000);
Adopted 2000, Initiative Measure No. 416.


Is the Nebraska marriage amendment extremely broad like Amendment 2, or does it narrowly deal with only the issue of marriage and close-substitutes for marriage?

The Eighth Circuit (in the Bruning case) upheld the Nebraska Marriage Amendment and said it is rationally-related to the legitimate interest in "steering procreation into marriage?" Is there a strong government interest in encouraging procreation to take place within a marriage between the procreating partners? In other words, is out-of-wedlock procreation a social problem that the state has a legitimate interest in discouraging? If so, is it rational to limit the "responsible procreation" program to couples whose sexual relationships might result in procreation?

Although the Romer Court said it was applying the rational basis test, some commentators view the decision as actually applying some kind of medium rare scrutiny to Amendment 2. Did Justice Kennedy's reluctance to ratchet up the level of review for sexual orientation discrimination affect the outcome of Bruning? How would the case come out under intermediate scrutiny or strict scrutiny?

Thursday, November 24, 2011

Guns Stop People From Killing People!

How about a little Second Amendment update!

In today's column, George Will posits this ironic headline from the mainstream media:

No one saw the possible problem with the word "despite" in this headline: "Gun crime continues to decrease despite increase in gun sales."

Have a great Thanksgiving.

Monday, November 14, 2011

Nebraska Marriage Amendment

Here is the text of the Amendment, Nebraska Constitution (art. I, sec. 29) , which I helped draft:


Only marriage between a man and a woman shall be valid or recognized in Nebraska. The uniting of two persons of the same sex in a civil union, domestic partnership, or other similar same-sex relationship shall not be valid or recognized in Nebraska.

Neb. Const. art. I, sec. 29 (2000);
Adopted 2000, Initiative Measure No. 416.

Is this Nebraska Amendment constitutional under the 14th Amendment?

Obamacare Case Granted Cert

The Gotham Times has the story.

Here is an excerpt:


The Supreme Court agreed to hear appeals from just one decision, from the United States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit, in Atlanta, the only one so far striking down the mandate. The decision, from a divided three-judge panel, said the mandate overstepped Congressional authority and could not be justified by the constitutional power “to regulate commerce” or “to lay and collect taxes.”
The appeals court went no further, though, severing the mandate from the rest of the law.
On Monday, the justices agreed to decide not only whether the mandate is constitutional but also whether, if it is not, how much of the balance of the law, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, must fall along with it.
Even the Obama administration, while arguing that the mandate is perfectly constitutional, has said that it is “absolutely intertwined” with two other provisions — one forbidding insurers to turn away applicants, the other barring them from taking account of pre-existing conditions. 

Some are calling this the Supreme Court's "Term of the Century" because so many important cases are before the Court this year.

Wednesday, November 02, 2011

What's Good For Peter and Paul


Is Good For Kody, Meri, Janelle, Christine and Robyn. No?

From the ReligionClause Blog:


"Sister Wives" Challenge Utah's Ban on Polygamy

A lawsuit was filed in federal district court in Utah yesterday by the polygamous family featured on the TLC series "Sister Wives" challenging the constitutionality of Utah's statute which bars polygamy.  The complaint (full text) in Brown v. Herbert, (D UT, filed 7/13/3011) summarizes the claims of Kody Brown and his 4 wives as follows:

To the extent that Article III of the Utah State Constitution, Utah Code Ann. §30-1-2, and ... §30-1-4.1 are used as the basis for the criminalization of plural relationships or families, the Brown family seeks a declaration that these laws are unconstitutional under the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment ... and the Free Exercise, Establishment, Free Speech, and Freedom of Association Clauses of the First Amendment....
According to the Salt Lake Tribune, plaintiffs' lawyer filing the lawsuit-- George Washington University Prof. Jonathan Turley -- at a press conference said: "We can’t embrace privacy as a principle and pick and choose who can enjoy it."  Utah Attorney General Mark Shurtleff says polygamy is different because it involves not just consenting adults, but also their entire families. According to AP, Utah has not prosecuted  prosecuted anyone for polygamy under its bigamy statute since 2003. However, according to the complaint in the lawsuit, the Browns have been subject to criminal investigations in Utah.

Sex for Phillies Tickets

Protected under Lawrence? Link

Suppose a man asks a woman on a date to attend the World Series. She accepts, goes to the game at his expense, and then they have sex at his apartment after the game. Protected under Lawrence?

Suppose a woman places an ad in the personals section of the New York Review of Books: "Busy forty-something professional woman seeks sexual relationship with busy professional man." They meet in a bar and she is arrested by the undercover police officer who responded to her ad? Protected under Lawrence?

Tuesday, November 01, 2011

Pro-Life Nurses Sue Hospital

Here is a Press Release about a law suit recently filed by ADF, a public interest law firm I often work with:


FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

12 nurses sue NJ hospital for forcing them to participate in abortions

ADF represents nurses in lawsuit against Univ. of Medicine and Dentistry of NJ
Tuesday, November 01, 2011

ADF attorney sound bite:  Matt Bowman
NEWARK, N.J. — Twelve nurses represented by Alliance Defense Fund attorneys filed suit Monday against their employer, a hospital run by the University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey, for requiring them to participate in abortions. Federal and state law both protect them from being forced to do so.

“Pro-life nurses shouldn’t be forced to assist in abortions against their beliefs,” said ADF Legal Counsel Matt Bowman. “No less than 12 nurses have encountered threats to their jobs at this hospital ever since a policy change required them to participate in the abortions regardless of their religious objections. That is flatly illegal.”

Federal law prohibits hospitals that receive certain federal funds from forcing employees to participate in abortions. UMDNJ receives approximately $60 million in federal funds annually. In addition, New Jersey law states, “No person shall be required to perform or assist in the performance of an abortion or sterilization.”

In September, UMDNJ initiated a policy change and began telling Same Day Surgery Unit nurses that they must assist abortions. The hospital imposed the policy on the nurses in October and repeatedly threatened that they must assist abortions or be terminated.

When one nurse objected to assisting abortions on the grounds of her religious beliefs, a supervisor responded that UMDNJ has “no regard for religious beliefs” of nurses who object to participating in abortions.

The hospital scheduled the nurses to begin training to assist abortions on Oct. 14. The training involves actually assisting surgical abortions, which the nurses believe is, in the words of the U.S. Supreme Court, “an act of violence against innocent human life.”

If the court does not issue an order requested by ADF attorneys that stops the training sessions while the lawsuit moves forward, the nurses and their colleagues will continue to be scheduled one by one to undergo the training and then to assist abortions on a regular basis. The lawsuit also requests that the hospital be ordered to return part of the federal taxpayer money it has received in light of its violation of federal law.

Demetrios K. Stratis, one of nearly 2,100 attorneys in the ADF alliance is local counsel in the case, Danquah v. University of Medicine and Dentistry of New Jersey. ADF is currently involved in a similar lawsuit in New York state court involving a nurse at Mt. Sinai Hospital.
  • Photo of nurse Lorna Jose-Mendoza, who is scheduled to assist with abortions Nov. 4 against her religious objections
  • Pronunciation guide: Bowman (BOH’-min)