As we leave the Establishment Clause behind, you should keep in my Justice ("Professor") Kavanaugh's summary of the current EC doctrine from his concurrence in American Legion:
"[T]he Court today applies a history and tradition test in examining and upholding the constitutionality of the Bladensburg Cross....And the cases together lead to an overarching set of principles: If the challenged government practice is not coercive and if it (i) is rooted in history and tradition; or (ii) treats religious people, organizations, speech, or activity equally to comparable secular people, organizations, speech, or activity; or (iii) represents a permissible legislative accommodation or exemption from a generally applicable law, then there ordinarily is no Establishment Clause violation. The practice of displaying religious memorials, particularly religious war memorials, on public land is not coercive and is rooted in history and tradition. The Bladensburg Cross does not violate the Establishment Clause. . . ."
No comments:
Post a Comment